Do their positions on public services, Indigenous rights and immigration reflect the values they claim to defend?
While I deeply respect many moments in Canadian conservative history, I find myself struggling to understand modern conservatism. I have several sincere questions for conservatives today, and I welcome thoughtful, substantive replies that help me see things from their point of view.
Some of the best decisions in Canadian history have been fully supported by conservative leaders. For example, it was Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper who apologized to those affected by Canada’s residential school system. Efforts to publicly fund health care were encouraged by Conservative leader John Diefenbaker. Canada is a great country because we engage in respectful dialogue and prioritize the well-being of all Canadians, especially the most marginalized.
To prioritize that well-being in practice, we must fund the services people rely on, which is why I am puzzled that conservative political platforms so often oppose tax increases. What is wrong with taxes? As a society, we pool our resources to provide fire protection, roads, utilities, schools, hospitals, and so on. We discuss how best to spend this money for the benefit of all. Why wouldn’t a person want to invest in this?
In Canada, economic conservatives insist on allowing for resource extraction. Is this good for our country beyond the short term? What about future generations? Fossil fuel supplies can be disrupted by unforeseen events. Meanwhile, countries around the world are investing more in renewable energy. Why are we investing in an industry facing an uncertain future as the world shifts toward cleaner energy?
Another issue I struggle to understand is conservative opposition to key parts of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada’s 2015 Calls to Action, including calls for governments to adopt and implement the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (UNDRIP), which sets out internationally recognized standards for protecting Indigenous rights.
To me, colonization was the theft of land and the deliberate marginalization of the people who already lived here. After a Conservative prime minister formally apologized for the residential school system, it is deeply troubling to see resistance to a framework designed to protect Indigenous rights and help us move forward together in a good way. For conservatives who oppose UNDRIP or other Calls to Action, how do you reconcile that opposition with a genuine commitment to justice and healing with our Indigenous neighbours?
Why is there such strong resistance among some modern conservatives to current immigration levels? Our country needs both workers and consumers because our fertility rate is very low. Of course, immigration needs to be regulated according to our economic needs, but we can manage immigration and deal with the pressures of a growing population.
And why is there such a focus on preserving a Eurocentric way of life? European cultures are wonderful, and English is a nice language, but diversity brings new ideas, new worldviews, and better ways of addressing the challenges of a changing world.
The idea that puzzles me the most is the conservative understanding of religion. I trace my Levantine Christian roots to the time of Jesus. I studied scripture and Christian philosophy in university. I don’t see a worldview presented that excludes people who believe differently. Christianity is about serving others without question. It is about living in a way that attracts others, rather than forcing them to conform. It is about seeing that man-made differences between groups of people are senseless in the eyes of God. How do conservative Christians ensure their actions reflect love for their neighbour rather than condemnation?
As a teacher, I consider myself fortunate to work each day with diverse groups of young people. Every class I teach is different, and each student is a unique gift to the world who offers a fresh perspective on the life we share. I don’t teach just to get through the day. I teach to help prepare my students for what I believe will be a very bright future.
I ask these questions of my conservative neighbours with genuine sincerity. I recognize that conservatism is not a single mindset and that social, fiscal and moderate conservatives all bring different priorities to the table. While some of these questions may speak more to one group than another, I hope they spark honest reflection and a thoughtful conversation among us all.
Gerry Chidiac specializes in languages and genocide studies and works with at-risk students. He received an award from the Vancouver Holocaust Education Centre for excellence in teaching about the Holocaust.
Explore more on Conservatism, Ethics, Aboriginal reconciliation, Immigration
The views, opinions, and positions expressed by our columnists and contributors are solely their own and do not necessarily reflect those of our publication.
Troy Media empowers Canadian community news outlets by providing independent, insightful analysis and commentary. Our mission is to support local media in helping Canadians stay informed and engaged by delivering reliable content that strengthens community connections and deepens understanding across the country.
0 Comments