Labour disputes cannot keep holding Canada’s economy hostage

Carney is right to introduce reforms to rein in costly strikes and lockouts

A much-overlooked element of the Carney government’s proposed Building Canada Strong Act is major labour relations reforms intended to bring greater predictability to federal responses to significant labour disputes.

Over the past three years, Canada has experienced labour disputes that have damaged our country’s reputation as a reliable international trading partner. Rail, port and airline stoppages have disrupted the economy and international trade.

On Sept. 21, the Carney government introduced Bill C-39, the Building Canada Strong Act, which includes changes to federal labour relations. The legislation passed second reading on Oct. 8 and is now before a parliamentary committee. It would clarify the circumstances under which the minister of jobs and families, Patty Hajdu, could intervene in a labour dispute affecting the national interest.

Section 107 of the Canada Labour Code already gives the federal labour minister broad powers to intervene in labour disputes. The proposed legislation would establish clearer conditions governing their use. The minister could refer questions to the Canada Industrial Relations Board or, subject to the new conditions, direct the board to act. Governments have used these powers to direct the board to order work to resume, extend an expired collective agreement or impose binding arbitration.

Canada has seen a surge in work stoppages in the transportation sector in recent years. While it normally makes sense to allow workers and employers to bargain over collective agreements, strikes or lockouts in the transportation sector threaten to grind the Canadian economy to a halt. Entire supply chains can be held hostage by a single union or employer. The federal minister must be able to step in.

We’re not talking about a small impact on our economy. In August 2024, when Canada’s two major freight rail systems shut down at the same time, the shutdown wreaked havoc on the Canadian economy. Together, the railways normally move at least $1 billion in goods each day. The Conference Board of Canada estimated that a four-week stoppage could have reduced Canada’s GDP by nearly $10 billion in 2024 and resulted in an average of 49,000 job losses over the year. Two labour disputes threatened to throw the entire country into turmoil.

Later that year, port lockouts in British Columbia and Montreal affected an estimated $1.2 billion in goods each day.

It’s one thing for strikes or lockouts to affect workers and employers. But when the entire national economy can be grounded, the government rightly feels compelled to act.

That’s why the Carney government is proposing these reforms. The federal government isn’t preparing to intervene in every labour dispute. Rather, it wants to ensure that when the national interest is genuinely affected, the government has a clear option to keep the economy moving. Given how much of an economic decline Canada has seen over the past decade, coupled with the ongoing trade conflict with the United States, the Carney government has little choice but to tackle this issue.

Of course, union leaders are up in arms. That should be a surprise to no one. But don’t buy their rhetoric. The Carney government isn’t preparing to end labour rights in Canada. The federal government simply wants the right tools to end the kind of labour dispute that could cost the economy billions and thousands of Canadians their livelihoods.

Under the proposed legislation, the federal minister could appoint a special mediator to work with the parties if they cannot reach an agreement. The mediator would generally have 21 days to help resolve the dispute and would submit a report if no agreement were reached. Before directing the Canada Industrial Relations Board to order workers back to work, extend a collective agreement or impose a binding method of settling the conflict, the minister would have to consider the mediator’s report and determine that the strike or lockout adversely affects, or could adversely affect, the national interest. A strike or lockout would also have to be underway before those powers could be exercised.

The labour relations element of the Building Canada Strong Act is a move in the right direction. It deserves Canadians’ support. Voters shouldn’t buy the spin from Canada’s big union bosses.

Dr. Jay Goldberg is a political scientist, a fellow with the Frontier Centre for Public Policy and a columnist whose work is syndicated in the Toronto Sun and Winnipeg Sun. His policy analysis focuses on fiscal, trade and energy issues.

Explore more on Unions, Liberal government, Canadian economy


The views, opinions, and positions expressed by our columnists and contributors are solely their own and do not necessarily reflect those of our publication.

© Troy Media

Troy Media empowers Canadian community news outlets by providing independent, insightful analysis and commentary. Our mission is to support local media in helping Canadians stay informed and engaged by delivering reliable content that strengthens community connections and deepens understanding across the country.

The Clarion, a Troy Media Partner

Independent journalism, free to read and use.

Daily commentary and analysis from Canada's trusted editorial network, Troy Media. All content is free to use, but you need a Troy Media account to download.

Register for free access Log in to your account

Trending News

Join the Discussion

We’d love to hear your thoughts. Become a free member to join our discussion threads. Troy Media welcomes civil, relevant discussion. Commenting is a privilege, not a right. All comments are subject to moderation.

By submitting a comment, you agree to our rules and policies.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

By commenting, you agree that:

  • Anonymous or false identities are not permitted
  • Personal attacks, defamation, hate speech, threats, spam, or off-topic posts will be removed
  • Comments must address the article, not other commenters
  • Moderation decisions are final

Troy Media may remove comments or close commenting at any time. If you want debate, argue ideas. If you want chaos, comment elsewhere.

Secret Link